Lupe Farkas / The Reading Room / Five-star review
BoneKeeper: The Lady of the Bones
659 pages, emotional damage and the unmitigated audacity of Magnus Attfield.
An extraordinarily ambitious fantasy, a psychologically fascinating protagonist and a cliffhanger that should probably be investigated by the appropriate authorities.

There should be legislation against authors who write 659 pages and finish with one of the biggest cliffhangers I have ever encountered in a book. Magnus Attfield deserves five stars for BoneKeeper: Part One — The Lady of the Bones. He should also expect a strongly worded letter from my solicitor.
Across 78 chapters, I laughed, questioned my own emotional stability and became thoroughly invested in a fictional woman whose understanding of the world frequently made me want to scream. By the time I finished, my supply of Coke Zero had suffered considerably. The author’s ability to create such an extraordinary character is what fascinated me most.
A woman who deserves a psychological dissertation
BoneKeeper is a magnificent contradiction. Her formidable strength exists alongside an almost heartbreaking innocence, making her simultaneously terrifying and endearing. I frequently wanted to reach through the pages, sit her down and explain several fundamental concepts concerning affection, personal boundaries and psychological warfare.
Attfield’s exploration of obedience and free will is particularly compelling. What happens when someone has been conditioned to interpret cruelty as affection? How can a person recognise manipulation when their entire understanding of love has been shaped by it? The novel approaches these questions through characterisation rather than lengthy psychological explanations. Some of its most devastating exchanges are also its simplest.
There is a peculiar helplessness in understanding something that a character cannot yet comprehend. I wanted to protect BoneKeeper, argue with her and occasionally give her a very stern lecture. The emotional investment she provoked is a testament to Attfield’s ability to give genuine psychological depth to a fantasy character.
Dark fantasy with a wicked sense of humour
Given the disturbing nature of some of the material, I was entirely unprepared for how funny this book could be. BoneKeeper’s gloriously literal interpretation of the world produces moments of comedy that had me laughing when I probably should have been questioning the psychological state of everyone involved.
Her humour works because she takes herself so seriously. Attfield understands the absurdity that emerges when people operate according to entirely different sets of assumptions. Those exchanges reveal as much about the characters as the darker passages do. I have little patience for fantasy novels in which everybody appears contractually obliged to remain miserable for several hundred pages. Fortunately, Magnus appears to share my objections.
A word from my inner editor
The sheer scale of Attfield’s imagination is impressive. His world feels expansive and his enthusiasm for it is unmistakable. There were occasions, however, when my inner editor reached for the red pen. Some passages would benefit from tighter pacing and a little less repetition, particularly when the emotional point has already been made.
A more rigorous edit would give the novel’s strongest moments even greater impact. These reservations did little to diminish my attachment to the characters. I remained curious and emotionally invested throughout, which is no small achievement in a manuscript of this length.
The audacity of that ending
Magnus, we need to have a conversation. After 659 pages and 78 chapters, you had the audacity to leave me with one of the biggest cliffhangers I have ever encountered in a book. I genuinely wanted to turn another page. There was no other bloody page.
As an author, I appreciate the effectiveness of that ending. As a reader, I reserve the right to be furious about it. I shall refrain from discussing the details, partly because I refuse to spoil the experience for anyone else and partly because my grievances are still remarkably fresh.
The Verdict / Lupe’s Rating
Five stars and a formal complaint
My philosophy concerning book ratings is simple. A novel can have editorial imperfections and still deserve five stars. If I finish the first volume of a series genuinely desperate to read the second, the author has accomplished something that flawless punctuation alone could never achieve.
BoneKeeper made me care. Its psychological complexity impressed me, its humour delighted me and its protagonist has remained on my mind. Magnus Attfield has earned his five stars. Now, where the bloody hell is Part Two?
Review copy disclosure: The author provided a complimentary EPUB of BoneKeeper for review. All opinions and the five-star rating are my own.
Lupe Farkas / Book & Author Links
Find BoneKeeper and Magnus Attfield
Kindle edition · Amazon
Buy BoneKeeper on KindlePaperback · Amazon
Find the paperback editionGoodreads · Book
Add BoneKeeper to your shelfGoodreads · Author
Follow Magnus AttfieldThe Reading Room
Explore more Lupe Farkas reviewsBoneKeeper: Part One — The Lady of the Bones · Magnus Attfield · 659 pages · Dark fantasy · Kindle ASIN B0HG7XR57K.
Powered by Coke Zero and books
Enjoyed this review? Offer me a Coke Zero.
Independent reviews, emotionally devastating fiction and a steady supply of literary chaos. Your support keeps the reading room going.
From the author / Keep reading
More dark stories from Lupe Farkas
The Chosen · Kindle
Witches, demons, the sacred and an impossible destiny. Explore the expanded dark edition.
Get The Chosen on AmazonThe Chosen · Read online
Explore the original serialised story and its complete chapter archive.
Read The Chosen onlineBefore October Ends · Book One
A psychological story for readers who prefer their fiction haunting and difficult to forget.
Explore Before October EndsBefore October Ends · Kindle
Discover the English Kindle edition of the novel.
Get Before October Ends
Response
[…] Imperfect Rebel — BoneKeeper review […]