I, Anomaly Book 1 • Science Fiction • Five-Star Review
I’M A WEAPON Apparently my first sci-fi book had to give me an existential crisis about robots
★★★★★
I almost said no to my first science fiction book. Then Sean Robins made me laugh in an email. Several hundred pages later, Coke Zero had come out of my nose and a sarcastic combat android had made me think about war, AI, empathy and what makes any of us human.
I almost said no to this book.
There. I admitted it.
When Sean Robins emailed me about I’m a Weapon, my first reaction was very simple: science fiction? Me?
This is my first proper science fiction book. It is not the kind of book I would normally pick for myself, and I was very close to politely saying no.
Then I read Sean’s email.
He was kind. He was funny. He was sarcastic. And somehow, before I had even opened his book, he had already managed to keep my attention.
So I thought: if this guy can write an email that makes me want to keep reading, what exactly is he going to do when someone gives him an entire book and unlimited time to play with words?
Well.
Now I know.
He made Coke Zero come out of my nose and then made me sit there thinking about war, morality, AI and what makes us human.
My First Sci-Fi Book. Of Course It Had to Do This to Me.
I genuinely did not know what I was going to do with spaceships, futuristic war, robots, military technology and all the things I normally assume belong to somebody else’s bookshelf.
Then I met Jack.
Jack is a combat android. He was created to follow orders, fight and function as a weapon.
Except Jack starts doing something extremely inconvenient.
He starts thinking.
He questions orders. He notices when something is wrong. He begins recognizing cruelty, kindness, stupidity, courage and fear. He starts building his own beliefs instead of simply accepting the ones placed inside him.
And that is where this stopped being a book I was reading outside my comfort zone and became a book I could not stop thinking about.
A Robot Learning Right From Wrong
We are talking about artificial intelligence constantly now.
What will it become? What will it learn? Can it understand us? Can it ever recognize right from wrong? Should we be frightened of what happens when machines begin making decisions?
And strangely, Jack made me feel reassured.
Because this is what I believe modernity should look like.
Not a machine simply copying us.
A machine learning with us.
Learning from the right humans. Learning from the wrong ones too. Watching what kindness does. Watching what cruelty does. Understanding that an order can exist and still be wrong. Understanding that intelligence without morality is not enough.
Jack does not suddenly wake up with a perfectly formed human conscience.
He builds one.
Piece by piece.
Choice by choice.
And I loved that.
Maybe the most important thing a thinking machine can learn from us is not how to obey humans, but how to recognize which parts of humanity are worth learning from.
Tears and Love Might Be the Hardest Things to Explain
This was the thought that stayed with me most after I finished.
I think tears must be one of the hardest things to explain to an artificial intelligence.
Love might be even harder.
How do you explain why losing somebody can physically hurt when nothing has touched your body?
How do you explain why somebody will put themselves in danger for another person when every calculation says they should walk away?
How do you explain loneliness?
Belonging?
Grief?
Or the strange moment when somebody becomes important to you and you cannot point to the exact second when it happened?
You can give a machine every definition ever written.
That does not mean it has experienced any of them.
And one of the things I loved most about I’m a Weapon is watching that distance between knowing and feeling slowly become smaller.
War Is Still War
And then there is the other side of this book.
War.
One of the saddest, ugliest things human beings have managed to repeat throughout history.
Sean writes a genuinely funny book around something that is not funny at all.
That balance impressed me.
The sarcasm never made me forget the sadness underneath it. If anything, the humour sometimes made the darkness hit harder because I would be laughing on one page and thinking about how cruel humans can be on the next.
And yes, there were several moments when I laughed so suddenly that Coke Zero came out of my nose.
I wish that were a metaphor.
It isn’t.
Jack’s observations about human behaviour, military logic, authority and our endless ability to make ridiculous decisions are hilarious.
But underneath the jokes, Sean keeps asking uncomfortable questions about obedience, violence, power and responsibility.
Sometimes the robot felt more human than the humans around him.
And that is both funny and a little devastating.
Jack Does Not Become Human. Jack Becomes Jack.
I think that distinction matters.
This is not simply a story about a robot becoming more human.
It is a story about a being becoming himself.
Jack develops opinions.
Beliefs.
Preferences.
Friendships.
A frankly ridiculous amount of sarcasm.
And eventually, his own sense of what is right and what is wrong.
That is what I found so reassuring about him.
A machine built to obey begins to understand that sometimes the most moral thing you can do is say:
No.
And somewhere along the way, while Jack is learning about humans, the humans around him are forced to reconsider what they think a machine can be.
Maybe both sides are learning.
Maybe that is the point.
And Sean Robins Can Write
I need to come back to the reason I accepted this book in the first place.
The email.
I was right.
If Sean could make an email funny enough to convince me to read a genre I normally would have declined, giving him a whole novel was apparently dangerous.
His writing is fast, sarcastic, ironic and genuinely funny, but it also knows when to stop joking.
There is heart underneath the metal.
There are questions underneath the explosions.
And there is a very human message underneath a story told through the eyes of someone who technically isn’t human at all.
I loved this book.
I loved Jack.
I loved Sean’s voice.
And I definitely want to read more.
Funny, sarcastic science fiction with a very human heart.
I thought I was agreeing to read a book about robots, futuristic war and things normally very far outside my reading comfort zone.
Instead I got a story about empathy, morality, free will, cruelty, friendship and the frighteningly simple question of what makes somebody capable of choosing right from wrong.
If you like sarcasm, robots, AI, science fiction and a genuinely good human message underneath all the action, this is a must-read.
And if science fiction is not normally your thing?
Apparently this is one hell of a place to start.
Five stars.
Sean, I want more Jack.
The Sarcasm
Sharp, ridiculous and perfectly timed. Jack’s observations about humans repeatedly caught me off guard, which is how Coke Zero ended up becoming part of this review.
The Humanity
The deeper Jack goes into understanding people, the more the book asks what empathy, conscience and choice actually mean.
The War
The humour never erases the cruelty of war. It sits beside it, which somehow makes both the laughter and the sadness land harder.
My First Sci-Fi
I nearly declined this because the genre felt outside my world. Instead it opened a door I definitely intend to walk through again.
Combat Android With Emotional Side Effects
- Coke Zero nasal incident: confirmed.
- Unexpected laughing in serious scenes: frequent.
- Existential thoughts about AI and humanity: extremely high.
- Faith in humans: challenged repeatedly.
- Faith in one sarcastic robot: alarmingly strong.
- Need for more Jack: severe.
Book Details
This One Is For You If…
- You love sarcastic protagonists and dry humour.
- You are fascinated by robots, AI, consciousness and free will.
- You enjoy science fiction with action but still want emotional and moral questions underneath it.
- You like stories that challenge blind obedience and ask what makes a choice truly yours.
- You are curious about sci-fi but, like me, do not normally reach for it first.
Authors, Publishers & Publicists
Want your book considered for an independent Lupe Farkas review? Read my review policy and submit through the ARC review portal.
Disclosure: I received a review copy of I’m a Weapon from the author for independent review consideration. This review reflects my own reading experience and opinion. No payment was received for the rating or review.
Have You Met Jack Yet?
If you have read I’m a Weapon, tell me what you thought in the comments. And if this would be your first science fiction book too, apparently we have both been warned.