Official author websiteNewsletter
Search
Eternal Ties by Katie Gabbert Downey book cover

Booksprout Review • Soul-Tie Series #1 • Paranormal Fantasy Romance • Released 1 September 2026

ETERNAL TIES

★★★½☆

3.5-Star Read Vampires Reincarnation Soul Ties

I genuinely do not know how to explain Eternal Ties without sounding slightly unhinged, so I am not even going to try.

Lupe Rating 3.5/5
Horny Level 1000/10
Supernatural Chaos EXTREME
Benley NEEDS A BOOK
Full Review by Lupe Farkas

I genuinely do not know how to explain Eternal Ties without sounding slightly unhinged, so I am not even going to try.

This book has A LOT going on: vampires, reincarnation, soul ties, shifters, magic, complicated relationships, questionable decisions, and enough supernatural chaos to keep throwing something new at you every time you think you understand where the story is going.

And horny? 1000/10.

This book does not flirt with spice. It kicks the door down, makes itself comfortable, and lives there.

Current supernatural conditions

Everyone is hot. Everyone notices that everyone is hot. Muscles are being observed. Attraction is happening everywhere.

Nobody in this supernatural universe appears to have been blessed with a low libido.

Under all that chaos, though, there are some genuinely interesting ideas.

I particularly liked the reincarnation and soul-tie elements, and the mythology becomes much more interesting as the story develops.

There were reveals toward the end that made me considerably more curious about where the series could go next.

For me, it occasionally felt like too many things were competing for attention at once, and some of the emotional back and forth became repetitive.

A little tightening would have made the story stronger.

Could everybody please stop being horny for four minutes so I can process what just happened?

Was this completely my usual kind of read? Probably not.

Was I entertained by the absolute supernatural madness of it all?

Absolutely.

And Benley deserves his own book.

For me, 3.5 stars.

The 3.5-star verdict

Too much supernatural chaos? Possibly. Entertaining? Absolutely.

Eternal Ties throws vampires, reincarnation, shifters, magic, soul bonds, relationship drama and high spice into the same supernatural blender and refuses to reduce the speed.

The reincarnation and soul-tie mythology were the pieces that interested me most, especially as later reveals began opening the door to a larger story.

I wanted more tightening and a little less repeated emotional back-and-forth, but curiosity about where the series goes next survived the chaos.

Loved

Soul Ties

The reincarnation and soul-bond mythology gave the chaos a more intriguing emotional and supernatural foundation.

There is a lot

The World

Vampires, shifters, magic, past lives and supernatural relationships keep expanding the story every time it seems settled.

My hesitation

Too Many Threads

At times, too many ideas and repeated emotional beats competed for attention. A little tightening would have helped.

Official petition

Benley

I have completed my assessment and reached a completely reasonable conclusion: Benley deserves his own book.

Book & review details

Title
Eternal Ties
Author
Katie Gabbert Downey
Series
Soul-Tie Series — Book One
Release Date
Review Copy
Booksprout
Lupe Rating
3.5 / 5 stars
Reader Metric
Horny Level: 1000 / 10
Genre
Paranormal Fantasy Romance
Best for readers who love

Vampires, reincarnation, soul bonds, shifters, supernatural mythology, messy relationships, high spice, complicated magical worlds and books that would rather give you six new problems than one quiet chapter.

Keep reading

More reviews from Lupe Farkas

I review ARCs and independently discovered books across fantasy, romance, psychological fiction, literary fiction and supernatural chaos in all its questionable forms.

Your turn

How much supernatural chaos is too much supernatural chaos?

And is there a legally enforceable limit on how many hot immortal people may occupy one book?

Authors & publishers

Reviews on LupeFarkas.com are independent. Receiving a complimentary or advance copy never guarantees a positive rating. Every accepted book receives an honest review based on my actual reading experience.

Thank you to Booksprout, Katie Gabbert Downey and everyone involved in bringing Eternal Ties to readers for the opportunity to read and review the book.

As always, these are entirely my own honest and independent thoughts.