ARC Review • Paranormal Cozy Mystery • Reader Damage Report
Reviewed by Lupe Farkas
MURDER AMONG THE HIVES
by Eloise Everhart
★★★★☆
A gentle paranormal mystery about rebuilding a life, surviving other people’s judgement, solving a murder, keeping bees, and accepting that sometimes your magical familiar is simply a cow. A COW. 🐮
Full Review
The mystery was interesting, especially because the beekeeping element gave the story a unique atmosphere.
But what stayed with me the most was not only the investigation.
It was Megan.
Megan is rebuilding her life inside a society that had already judged her, condemned her, and decided who she was before truly knowing her.
That was the emotional part of the book for me.
I liked watching her step back into the world, take up space, and slowly prove that she is more than the reputation other people placed upon her.
There is something deeply satisfying about watching a woman reclaim her own identity after a community has already written an entire story about her.
Megan does not simply investigate a mystery. She is also investigating the life she wants to build and the person she wishes to become after everything that happened to her.
And then there is Gertie.
A cow familiar.
A COW!!! 🐮
I have to respect the originality.
In a genre full of cats, ravens, magical dogs, and suspiciously intelligent owls, a cow familiar was definitely memorable.
Gertie brought a uniquely cozy form of chaos to the story, and honestly, paranormal fiction needs more cows.
I also enjoyed the loyalty and friendships in the book.
I love when characters are layered, when first impressions are not everything, and when actions slowly reveal who people really are.
May all friends be like that, honestly.
My only reason for not giving this five stars is that I personally wanted a little more emotional attachment earlier in the story.
The investigation follows a classic cozy-mystery structure, with several suspects, conversations, clues, and interviews.
At times, I wished the pacing had been tighter and the emotional connection to the characters had arrived sooner.
I wanted a stronger emotional pull in the middle of the book—something that made me feel more personally invested while the investigation moved from one suspect to another.
But I also need to be fair: detective stories are not naturally my favourite genre.
I am the kind of reader who wants to crawl directly into a character’s emotional crisis and stay there. Traditional suspect interviews require me to behave like a responsible member of an investigation team, and apparently I am not qualified. 😂
For readers who love classic amateur-sleuth mysteries in the style of Murder, She Wrote, this structure will probably be exactly what they are looking for.
You have a close community, a determined woman asking questions, multiple suspects, secrets hiding behind ordinary lives, and a mystery slowly solved through observation and conversation.
Overall, this was a cozy, gentle, and enjoyable start to a paranormal mystery series.
It has a lovely magical atmosphere, an unusual beekeeping setting, loyal friendships, a distinctive familiar, and a main character I would like to see grow even more.
Megan has only just started reclaiming her place in the world, and I think the most interesting parts of her story may still be ahead.
I would definitely return to this world. Preferably when Gertie is available. 🐮🐝🌸
Best for readers who love
paranormal cozy mysteries, classic amateur detectives, Jessica Fletcher-style investigations, magical small towns, beekeeping, found family, loyal friendships, misunderstood women rebuilding their lives, gentle mysteries, eccentric familiars, multiple suspects, and cows refusing to accept that cats normally get all the magical jobs
Lupe damage level
0/10
No emotional injuries detected. I left calm, cozy, and significantly more interested in acquiring a cow familiar.
Cozy mystery level
9/10
Bees, magic, friendships, suspects, a small community, and murder presented with no desire to permanently ruin your week.
Cow familiar originality
10/10
Cats have controlled paranormal fiction for long enough. Gertie has entered the chat. 🐮
Join the Reader Chaos
Follow Lupe Farkas
Follow me for honest reviews, ARC adventures, strange mysteries, complicated fictional people, suspicious quantities of tabs, unexpected cows, and books that rearrange my brain chemistry.
Tell Me What to Read Next
Have you read Murder Among the Hives?
Leave a comment below and tell me what you thought. Did you solve the mystery before Megan? And, more importantly, where do you stand on cows becoming the new official familiars of paranormal fiction?
Send me books you think I should read next. Cozy mysteries, complicated women, witches, strange houses, magical animals, emotional damage, family secrets, and fictional people making questionable decisions are always welcome.
Follow the blog using the Subscribe button below the post so the next review arrives before common sense can interfere.
Authors, Publishers & Publicists
Would you like me to review your book?
If you are an author, publisher, publicist, or ARC team and would like me to consider your book for review, send me the title, synopsis, genre, publication date, and review-copy information.
I review with honesty, psychological attention, emotional evidence, and full Lupe Farkas reader-chaos mode.
lupe@lupefarkas.comDisclosure: I received an advance review copy of this book through BookSirens. This review is honest, voluntary, and written in full Lupe Farkas reader-chaos mode.
Thank you to BookSirens, the publisher, and Eloise Everhart for providing me with an advance copy of Murder Among the Hives. All opinions, detective-related struggles, beekeeping curiosity, and demands for more cow familiars are entirely my own. 🐝🐮
More Reviews